Tue 30 Sep 2014
Why did Herbert Lehman not get an honary degree?
Posted by David Dudley Field '25 under Williams History at 7:40 am
Four years ago, Henry Bass ’57 wrote:
I do think Ephdom has a problem with excessive decorem. Perhaps considerable decorem is necessary to get faculty particiapation in this blog. I only hope the faculty will allow a little more controversy than they find really comfortable.
Some will, and some won’t.
Years ago I wrote the Willliams administration saying they should allow a little more controversy in trustee elections by allowing long campaign statements such as those in Harvard elections. I got a polite letter back telling me that, “Harvard grads may run for the office overseer, but that Williams grads stood for office of trustee.”
A great line! There is something to be said for the Williams tradition of decorum and — Dare I say it? — gentlemanly behavior. This tradition is one reason that the Williams campus is less riven by ideological disputes than other elite colleges. Still, we ought to at least allow trustee candidates to tell us what they think! Back to Henry:
Williams once did have a candidate with deep beliefs, Herbert Lehman, who ran for the US Senate in New York and was elected several times on very liberal platforms. And his family gave Williams lots of money. But, Williams was so offended by his brashness and liberal beliefs that it never even gave him an honorary degree.
True story? There is a great history thesis to be written about Williams and the Lehman family. Who will write it?


« Phi Beta Kappa History | SAT Score History » |
One Response to “Why did Herbert Lehman not get an honary degree?”
You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post
If a comment you submitted does not show up, please email us at eph at ephblog dot com. Please note that commenters are required to use a valid email address when submitting comments.
frank uible says:
My SWAG is that the essential answer to the question raised in the title is not adherence to decorum/gentlemanly behavior or even to subtle limits on faculty or other speech but to plain and simple anti-Semitism. Back in the day anti-Semitism was far more extensive, open and virulent than today – especially in the northeast, including (heaven forfend) Williams College.
October 1st, 2014 at 2:53 am