Screen Shot 2018-07-13 at 7.26.50 AM

The Admissions Office was, undoubtedly, impressed by Dula’s essays and teacher recommendations.

Oh, wait! This was posted on July 5th. Dula has not written his application essays nor has he sought any teacher recommendations.

None of which is Dula’s fault. He does not make the rules. He is a subject of a system which expects him to create videos of his athletic performance while his family pays thousands of dollars to participate in various club teams and showcase events. The pay-off comes when Williams tells him, during the summer of his junior year in high school, that he has been admitted.

And I have no particular problem with this system, except with the hypocrisy which comes, not from Dula, but from Williams, from the College’s constant pretending that athletics is just one “attribute” among many, that Admissions treats exceptional violin players the same way we treat exceptional lacrosse players. We don’t.

And Dula is far from the only already-admitted member of the class of 2023. Congratulations, also, to Jacob Cohn ’23.

Screen Shot 2018-07-13 at 3.04.10 PM

Athletic admissions at Williams has very little to do with normal admissions. The vast majority of the 70 tips (and 30 or so protects) are told by a coach, in the summer after their junior year of high school, that they will be admitted to Williams if they apply early decision. No one cares about their personal essays or teacher recommendations.

Other examples of early athletic admissions this year include Nick Altmann and, lest you think this is only about male athletes, Emma Lynch.

The most offensive aspect to this whole process is how much time it takes away from under-paid high school teachers. Even though Lynch has already been admitted to Williams, the College will still require her to submit recommendation letters, so some poor Weymouth math teacher is going to get to spend an October evening writing a letter about her that no one will ever read . . .

Print  •  Email